Decisive Losses (part 2)

Share

Content Warning: corporal punishment

The truck hummed beneath them, headlights sweeping the empty road. Robin sat rigid on the bench seat, fingers digging into the soft pajama pants. The cane and the bag were in the bed behind them.

Dad broke the quiet first. “You did well today.”

Robin blinked. “Sir?”

“No-win scenario.” His voice was low, steady. “Three against one. Knife. Threats. You walked out with your skin intact…” The turn signal clicked, rhythmic. “Most people freeze. Or panic.”

Her throat tightened. “I stabbed a kid in the eye.”

“You survived.” His grip shifted on the wheel. “That’s what matters. And you thought. In the truck, breaking it down; most adults can’t do that under pressure or, for that matter, with all the time in the world to think. You’re twelve.”

She stared at her lap. The pajama fabric was soft, too soft. “I should’ve done better.”

“I’m sure you will next time.” He’s eyes stayed on the road. “That’s the difference between you and them. You learn.”

The gates loomed ahead, wrought iron curled into vicious points. Dad rolled down the window, prepared to use the intercom, but the metal groaned open for them.

“Two things,” he said, after the window was back up. “You apologize before. You apologize after.”

Robin went cold. “For what?”

“For existing.” His tone was only slightly sardonic. “You thank Mr. MacDougal for his generosity. For not pressing charges. For his understanding.”

Her hands clenched. “He’s letting his son—⁠”

“No.” Dad’s tone sliced through her. “You don’t get to be right. Not tonight. Tonight, you have to be smart. Take that feeling and put it away for later. I know you can do that.”

Robin looked at him with surprise. How could he know that about her? Was he like her? “I know… I just wanted to complain for a sec’ before we started… Billy’s a rotten apple.”

Dad chuckled. “He is indeed.”

The driveway stretched, an endless ribbon of smooth pavement up a gentle hill, lined by short trees, crabapple perhaps. All the while the mansion rose ahead, all sharp angles and cold stone.

Dad pulled into the loop by the front door. The engine died and silence pressed in.

He stepped out and retrieved the bags from the truck bed.

The front door opened before they reached it. A man in a suit stood framed in the light, face unreadable. Dad didn’t hesitate. He stepped forward, Robin trailing like a shadow.

The foyer was marble, vast and echoing. Dad’s shoes clicked against the floor. Robin’s soft Mary Janes made no sound.

“Mr. MacDougal.” Dad’s voice was smooth, deferential. “Thank you for having us to your lovely home.”

Mr. MacDougal wore a smile that didn’t reach his eyes. “Mark.” His voice was oil over gravel. “Glad you could make it.”

MacDougal’s gaze flicked to Robin. Lingered. “This him?”

“Her…” She started quietly. “Thank you, sir,” she said, voice steady, “for not pressing charges. What I did was wrong and very dangerous, and I deserve to be punished.”

MacDougal’s lips curled, not quite a smile. “At least he’s got manners.”

He turned, gesturing toward the hall. “My wife and Billy are in the study. Let’s get this over with.”

The study was all dark wood and deep shadows, the kind of room that swallowed sound. Billy sat in an armchair, one leg propped up, a bandage taped over his eye. His other eye locked onto Robin the second she walked in.

She didn’t flinch.

“Billy,” Mrs. MacDougal said, “this is the little freak who put you in the hospital?”

Billy’s mouth twisted. “Yeah.”

Robin stepped forward before Dad could stop her. “I’m so sorry for hurting you,” she said, and she surprised herself by meaning it. The words came easily. “You have no idea how relieved I was to hear you’re going to be okay.”

Billy blinked. His fingers dug into the armrest. “You… what?”

She held his gaze then looked up to Mr. MacDougal. “I am not here to make excuses. My side of the story is not important.”

For a second, the room was still. Then Billy laughed, a sharp, ugly sound. “Oh, fuck you.”

Dad’s grip on her shoulder tightened. MacDougal sighed, like this was all beneath him.

“Enough,” he said. “Let us put this unpleasantness behind us as quickly as possible.”

“May we use this table?” Dad asked.

MacDougal waved a dismissive hand. “Be my guest.”

Dad set the cane against the table, then pulled a pair of latex gloves from his pocket. He snapped them on, one at a time; the sound was obscenely loud in the quiet room.

Then he reached into the bag. The metal rod glinted under the lamplight as he pulled it free: smooth, rounded at the end, no thicker than a pen but shorter. He held it up, turning it slowly so everyone could see.

Robin didn’t look away.

Dad stepped closer. The rod was cold when he pressed it to the outer corner of her eye. His other hand cupped the back of her head, steadying her.

“Don’t squint but keep your eye shut,” he murmured. “Don’t move.”

She didn’t squint and she didn’t move.

The rod slid in in one smooth motion. Pressure, sharp and invasive, then a deep, grinding ache as it settled. Her vision was filled with galaxies of stars. A gasp and a moan tore from her throat, raw and animal. Dad had been right, it wasn’t extreme pain, but it was absolutely unignorable.

“I’m sorry, Billy.” Her voice cracked. “I should’ve just let you. I tried to just let you.”

Billy’s face twisted. For a second, he looked sick. Then his smirk returned, but it was brittle now. “Yeah. You should’ve.”

Dad didn’t let her recover. He guided her to the table, bent her over it. The wood was cool against her stomach. He adjusted her position, just so, and turned her head gently, so the rod stayed in place, her injured eye away from the table.

“Keep your head still,” he ordered. “Eyes shut. Don’t move.”

“Yes, sir,” she whispered shakily.

The handcuffs were cold as they clicked around her wrists. Dad quickly secured them to the table leg with a short piece of cord, then did the same with her ankles.

Dad’s fingers hooked the waistband of her pajama pants and eased them down to her knees. Robin kept her thighs pressed together to keep everything hidden in front.

Billy’s chair creaked as he leaned forward. “You’re really gonna…?”

“Six strokes,” Dad said, picking up the cane again. He flexed and swung it, the rattan whistling. “Judicial standard. Malaysia, Singapore, places where they don’t tolerate violence in schools.” His voice was calm, almost clinical. “Seventeen-year-old boy, convicted of grievous injury to a classmate? This is what he’d get.”

MacDougal crossed his arms. “And you think that’s fair?”

Dad met his gaze and spoke slowly. “I think it’s settled.”

Robin’s breath came in shallow bursts. The rod in her eye throbbed, a deep, insistent pulse. She focused on that: on the pain she already knew, the one she could endure.

Dad stepped back, measuring his stance.

“This ends it,” he said, more to Robin than anyone else. “After this, we walk away.”

She swallowed.

The cane hissed through the air.

The impact was a white-hot brand. She screamed, couldn’t help it, the sound ripping from her lungs before she could think. Her body jerked against the cuffs and they clanked, but the table held. The rod in her eye didn’t move but the galaxies in the dark spun and swirled.

“One,” Dad said.

Billy’s breath was audible, ragged. His good eye was wide, locked onto the reddening stripe across her skin.

The second stroke landed slightly lower, but to Robin it felt like the same exact spot. She broke, a keening, wordless noise, her fingers clawing at the table. The pain was everywhere, searing, and the rod in her eye pulsed in time with her heartbeat.

“Two.”

Mrs. MacDougal made a small, disapproving sound. Mr. MacDougal himself didn’t move, but his jaw was tight.

Dad waited the same ten seconds as between the first two strokes and then laid the third perfectly parallel and even below the second. Robin’s scream was starting to sound hoarse now. Tears streamed down her face, puddling on the table. She was sure that she must be bleeding everywhere; it would be impossible not to after pain like that.

“Three.”

The cane whooshed and thwacked against her skin, the sound obscene in the quiet room. The fourth stroke landed just above where her bum met her thighs. She couldn’t scream anymore; could only gasp, her body shaking.

“Four.”

Mrs. MacDougal spoke up, “Victor, must we? Look at the poor child.”

Mr. MacDougal murmured in agreement, but Billy spoke first. “That freak could have killed me!”

The fifth stroke hit just below the crease of her butt and her legs went slack. She whimpered, her breath coming in wet, shuddering gasps.

“Five.”

One more. She knew it was coming. Knew it would hurt. Knew she couldn’t stop it. The anticipation was the most intense feeling she had ever felt.

The sixth stroke cut diagonally across the previous five in a perfect “farm gate” pattern and from each spot the strokes crossed, blood began to trickle. She screamed silently, her body arching, and the stars filled her vision completely. The rod shifted, and she sobbed, her nails scratching helplessly into the table.

“Six.”

The only sounds in the room were Robin’s gasps and sobs.

Dad quickly set the cane down. His breath was steady, but his hands trembled. He didn’t look at anyone; just at Robin.

She didn’t speak. Couldn’t. Her body was fire, her eye a throbbing agony. She could taste blood in her mouth from biting her lip.

Dad reached for the rod. “This comes out now. It’ll hurt,” narrating for the room as much as Robin.

She nodded. Or tried to. Her head barely moved.

One smooth pull.

The rod slid free and she moaned from the overwhelming discomfort of it. Snot ran down her face. She could breathe again, but the relief was drowned in the aftershocks of pain.

Dad dropped the rod onto the table with a clink. It rolled, leaving a faint smear of pink on the polished wood.

MacDougal cleared his throat. “That’s… settled, then.”

Dad turned to Billy. “Are we all agreed on that?”

“No, I should have been the one to do it,” he replied.

“Billy!” Both parents gasped nearly in unison.

Dad replied to him directly, “I’m sorry, young master, but what I just did takes skill. But I did bring a more suitable implement for you.” He spoke to Billy but his eyes were on his parents. He pulled out the scourge and when his parents failed to object, he handed it to Billy. “Go ahead, sir. We’ll stay as long as we must to ensure there is no future animosity between our families.”

Billy gripped the scourge’s handle and inspected it, the thorns glinted. Then he brought it down.

Unlike the whoosh of the cane, the strike was preceded by only a tiny hiss of air. Then pain: sharp, stinging, like several bee stings at once landing across the cuts on her bottom. Dad had hoped he would start there, because now the implement was a paintbrush full of blood and everywhere he hit would show it regardless of how much new damage it did. Robin gasped, and then started to wail, a long and pitiful sound while her body jerked against the restraints. Thin lines of blood welled instantly.

Billy laughed, a raw, ugly sound. He swung again.

This time, the thorns bit deeper. Robin screamed, her voice breaking. The pain wasn’t the cane’s blunt agony; it was jagged, spreading, like fire ants swarming her skin. She didn’t have to play it up.

“Billy,” Mrs. MacDougal said, her voice tight. “That’s enough.”

He didn’t listen.

The third strike landed across her thighs. The thorns caught, tore. Robin’s breath came in ragged sobs, her fingers clawing at the table. Blood ran in rivulets now, pooling at her feet.

Billy’s face was flushed, his good eye wild. “Fucking freak,” he spat, swinging again and again. “Bitch.” He worked her calves, her thighs, her butt, over and over. “Cunt.”

“Billy,” chided Mrs. MacDougal.

Robin’s wailing was a steady, guttural, wordless thing. Blood spattered the floor, the table, the walls. Some even hit the ceiling. Some landed on the white gauze of Billy’s eye patch.

Dad didn’t move. He didn’t flinch when he felt blood land on his cheek. He just watched, his expression unreadable.

Billy’s breath was ragged, his chest heaving. He raised the scourge again…

“Billy,” Mr. MacDougal said, sharper this time. “Enough.”

Billy ignored him and brought it down again.

Dad glanced across at Mr. MacDougal who was still on the couch. Then he turned toward Billy and leaned in, his voice a low murmur, “Go ahead. Fuck her.”

Billy froze. Then something ugly moved behind his eye. His pants dropped.

That was the line.

Mr. MacDougal leaped from the couch and lunged, grabbing Billy’s shoulder. “That’s ENOUGH!”

Billy snarled, trying to shake him off. “Let me!—⁠”

“No.” His father’s voice was iron. “This is done.”

Robin sagged against the table, her body trembling, her skin burning. Blood and sweat ran down her legs and mostly soaked into her pajama bottoms but some reached her bare feet, slippery against the tile. She didn’t remember her shoes coming off.

Dad quickly pulled her pants back up and covered her with a soft fleece blanket. “Keep your eyes closed and still,” he commanded. She flinched when he touched the handcuffs to remove them. Her wrists ached where the restraints had bitten in, but it was nothing compared to the rest of it. He lifted her legs so that she lay on the table under the blanket. Then he quickly packed everything up while Robin slowly caught her breath and settled into a more quiet type of crying.

He left the lynchpin where it sat.

Mr. MacDougal recoiled at the sight of Billy’s erection, marked with the deep purple bruise of Robin’s teeth. He shoved the boy away, hard enough that he stumbled, and nearly fell. “Look at what you’ve done,” he hissed, voice low and venomous. “Look at her!”

She didn’t move. The blanket changed something. The warmth, the softness, the simple fact that it was over; her muscles unclenched one by one, and she realized that she was in regular pain, the kind you’d complain about and they’d give you a pill and in a little while it would help. Her body was habitable again.

Billy’s breath came in ragged gasps. His good eye filled with tears and his chin quivered. He yanked his pants up, his movements jerky, angry. He stormed toward the door, almost running, his shoulder slamming into the frame as he left.

The pants clung to the blood on her bum, warm and sticky, and she didn’t mind. It felt like being held. She sighed as a deep relaxation fell over her and she realized that somehow, impossibly, she felt really good in that moment. She wished Athena was there, she wanted nothing more in the world than to be held.

Mr. MacDougal turned to Robin. His voice was rough, but not unkind. “Miss Bertucci.” He swallowed. “I… owe you an apology.”

Robin didn’t lift her head and her eyes were still closed. Her voice was a wrecked thing, but she forced the words out. “I apologize too… I hurt your son… I bit him… And I stuck a pen in his eye.” Another sob tore through her. “I’m so sorry.” She remembered her instructions, “Thank you for not pressing charges.”

MacDougal exhaled sharply. His hand lifted, then fell. Like he wanted to reach for her and thought better of it. “You were defending yourself.”

She shook her head, just a little. “I know.” She took a ragged breath. “But I still hurt him… and it could have been worse… I deserved this.”

Dad pressed a wad of gauze over her eye and taped it down. “You should still keep both eyes closed and still as much as you can, but now you can open your other eye if you feel like you need to.” As he spoke his hand settled on her shoulder. She leaned into it without thinking.

Mrs. MacDougal made a small, distressed sound. “Victor—⁠”

“I know, Eleanor!” MacDougal’s voice was steel. He didn’t take his eyes off Robin. “Miss Bertucci… You have my word. Billy will not come near you again.”

Robin nodded. “Thank you, sir,” she whispered.

MacDougal’s mouth pressed into a thin line. He looked at Dad. “Mark.”

Dad didn’t move. “Yes?”

“This is settled.”

Dad’s grip on Robin’s shoulder tightened. “It is.”

MacDougal turned on his heel and left out the same door as Billy, swift and purposeful. His wife hesitated, her gaze lingering on Robin: on the blood, the blanket, the shivering. “Let me show you out,” she said quietly.

“Ma’am, she’s shivering pretty bad. Would you mind staying with her while I warm up the truck?”

Mrs. MacDougal’s eyes widened at being trusted without deserving it, but she nodded.

Dad helped Robin curl up under the blanket, still on the table, and handed her a juice box. “Drink slowly. I’ll be right back,” he said, and left them, taking the bags.

Mrs. MacDougal didn’t move, the way she’d sat in the study while Billy swung the scourge.

Then, carefully, she reached in and tucked the blanket tighter around Robin’s shoulders. Her fingers lingered, just for a second, on the girl’s hair.

“I’m sorry,” she whispered. “I should have stopped it sooner.”

Robin’s eyes were closed. “We’re still young,” she murmured. “You’ve still got time.”

Mrs. MacDougal’s hand went to her mouth, then she slowly straightened, composing herself before Dad returned.

When he did, he said, “You’re still shivering, so we need to get you warm and I’m not letting you walk. I can carry you like a laundry basket, which will hurt the backs of your knees. Or I can throw you over my shoulder like a sack, which won’t press on anything. What’s your preference, my love?”

“Sack is fine,” she said in a hoarse rasp.

“Tell me immediately if you feel light-headed or start seeing more stars than you do right now.” He was as gentle as he could be and slid her stomach from the table onto his shoulder and then lifted. Mrs. MacDougal went ahead to open the front door and then the truck’s door.

Dad carefully set Robin across the bench seat on her stomach. He shook the juice box in her hand; it was still half full. “Small sips. Don’t stop until it’s empty.” And he studied her face: her eye, her breathing, the color in her lips. Whatever he was looking for, he found it. He stood and closed the door.

Robin pressed her forehead against the cool vinyl. She could hear nothing of their conversation over the sound of the heater and the rumble of the engine.