Decisive Wins
Content Warning: rape
After rinsing the toothpaste from her mouth, Robin sang a lowering glide on “Ooooh.”
“Why do you do that every day?” asked Athena, in her fuzzy bathrobe, after she finished brushing.
“One day soon, my voice is going to break. And I want to find out at home, not in school in front of everybody.”
Athena gave her a quick hug and led her back to the bedroom where the morning light slanted through the blinds, painting stripes across their beds. “Just socks and panties, I want you to try on your gym outfit.”
Soon, Athena was holding up two sports bras: one black, one neon pink. “This one,” Athena said, tossing the pink at Robin’s chest. “It’ll show under the tank. Make it obvious you’re a girl.”
Robin pulled the fabric taut between her fingers. The material was thin, stretchy. “Won’t it… chafe?”
Athena smirked, already digging through her drawer. “You’ll live. Besides, you like a little discomfort if it reminds you of me, right?” She tossed a pair of tight green spandex shorts next. “These’ll hug your hips right. Show off that ass I love so much.”
Robin’s face warmed, but she didn’t argue and stepped into the shorts. The fabric clung like a second skin. Athena watched, arms crossed, then nodded approval.
“Turn.” Athena made a face. “VPL problem.” She rummaged in the drawer.
“What’s VPL?”
“Visible Panty Line,” she said, handing her a thong.
Robin changed the underwear and modeled the shorts again. Athena adjusted the waistband, her fingers brushing the small of Robin’s back. “Good. Now the tank.” She pulled a cropped white top over Robin’s head, smoothing the fabric down her torso. The sports bra’s pink straps peeked out from the armholes, bright against Robin’s pale skin. Athena stepped back, tilting her head. “Damn. I think I’d like to play gym coach later.”
Robin had trouble reaching the sports bra and pulling it over her head. This time, Athena didn’t help; she just leaned against the bedpost, grinning as Robin twisted her arms behind her back. Eventually, she yanked it off, the pink fabric snapping her face in the process.
Athena pushed off the post and rummaged through her closet. “Here.” She held up a sundress, pale yellow, sleeveless, the hem fluttering just above the knee. “Last chance for this one before winter hits. At least to wear it without tights.”
Robin let her pull the dress over her head, the fabric cool against her skin. Athena adjusted the collar, then clipped Robin’s hair up on the left side: one pink clip, one blue.
Athena reached into her nightstand and pulled out the pronoun buttons they had made together. She held up Robin’s. “Badass.” She turned it so Robin could see the pronouns were still crisp and bold, but the background had two spots darkened by dried blood. She pinned it to Robin’s dress just next to the bandage below her collarbone. Then she put on her own button in the same spot.
Their eyes met. Athena’s chin lifted briefly, like she was saying, go get ’em.
The warning bell rang, and Robin slipped into her homeroom seat. She kept her head down, fingers gripping the edge of her desk. The teacher said nothing about the button or about the bandage covering the injury he had caused the day before. Someone loudly said, “Good morning, tranny,” and the teacher, sounding bored, said, “That’s enough.”
It wasn’t much, but it was something. It was a start.
But the halls between classes were still a gauntlet. Monday had only been the seventh graders. Today it came from 8th and 9th grade as well.
A huge boy, football jersey stretched over his shoulders, “accidentally” shoulder-checked her into the lockers. His friends laughed as he turned back, palm slapping the wall beside her head. “Whoops.”
An older girl from cheer squad smirked as she “helped” Robin pick up her dropped books, her nails scraping Robin’s chest. “You’re almost pretty,” she murmured, loud enough for her friends to hear. “If you had tits.”
There were boys who groped her casually, without even slowing down. She wondered how much of that was normal. She made a mental note to ask Athena. Who knows, maybe that was acceptance… She tried to make it feel affirming and wasn’t completely unsuccessful.
Three seventh graders cornered her by the water fountain. One yanked the back of her dress over her head and held it while another jammed his hand between her legs from behind, squeezing. “Where’s your dick at, freak?” His thumb pressed hard against the tape over her clit, and she gasped as the adhesive gave way, the sudden slackness making her stomach lurch. She clamped her thighs shut, but his fingers still wormed in, groping until she twisted free. She pressed a hand to her stomach as she walked to a bathroom to fix it, the tape half-peeled, her clit throbbing where the jerk had pinched it.
She stopped counting insults at twenty, and that was before 4th period. Physical contact: nine, with six to her genitals or chest. By then she was no longer inside her body. Instead she was watching from above and controlling it like a puppet.
Her fingers found the gold studs in her ears, still tender from two nights ago. She twisted one slowly, feeling the sting bloom and fade. It felt good in a way she couldn’t explain. Athena’s hands had put them there.
Between fourth and fifth periods, Billy, and his clean white shoes, blocked her path. The hall was thick with bodies, but the space around him was clear, like always. His gaze dragged over her and his lips curled. “I’ll see you in sixth period, darling,” he said, and then left before Robin could reply.
That was a clear problem but she was good at clear problems. She found a small neurodivergent boy who was also in her gym class, a boy who was almost surely also a victim of bullying, and pulled him aside on his way to lunch. “Listen, if you’re my partner in gym class, I’ll let you win and it will seem like you’re a better fighter than Billy.” He seemed to hesitate. “I don’t plan on staying here on the bottom of the pecking order, you’re not going to get a better chance than this to improve your standing in this place.” He nodded. “Thank you, you won’t regret it. What is your name?”
“Henry.”
“My name is Robin. Henry, someday, I hope we’re friends.”
From there, she beelined for the library with her bag lunch, where Mrs. Hendricks, the librarian, let her into her office again. When she finished she moved to one of the library computers and typed puberty blockers into the search bar.
Access Denied.
This site has been blocked by the district filter.
She tried bottom surgery. Same result. HRT. Blocked. How to get estrogen. Blocked. But major news sites were whitelisted and she was able to find some information on there, but it was mostly bad news about states prohibiting things.
And far too soon, it was time for gym.
The locker room stank of sweat and the fake pine smell of cheap deodorant. Robin kept her back to the lockers. She slid her panties off under her dress and pulled the thong and shorts on before taking it off. She remembered how the green spandex made her thighs look good: thicker, her hips wider.
While she was pulling up the spandex under her dress, someone shoved her and she stumbled. Before she could recover, he snatched her cartoon panties from the locker. She didn’t react while the boy ran around the room with his trophy. Then the coach came out and took them and threw them in the trash in his office. She finished by pulling off her dress and quickly locking it up. Only then did she pull the tank over the pink bra.
She caught Billy MacDougal’s gaze as he tied his shoes, his smirk slow and deliberate. “Nice legs, Robin,” he drawled. A few of his friends snickered.
The wrestling mats did little to mute the sharpness of the Coach’s whistle. Robin stuck to the perimeter during warm-ups and stayed close to Henry. Then Coach blew the whistle again. “Partner drills! Find someone and a spot on the mats!”
The room filled with groans and shuffling. Billy ambled in front of her, grinning. “Guess we’re stuck with each other.”
“Sorry, not today, Billy. I’m already partnered with Henry.” She spoke with a flat factual politeness, but she stood straight and proud. She looked good and she knew it. She held back all the clever jabs that came to mind. The goal was not to provoke.
But she had already failed. Billy left fuming and partnered with one of his cronies. Throughout the period, she kept catching his sneer being directed at her.
Henry was terrible. Robin had to work not to pin him by accident; every time she left an opening he missed it, and every time she gave ground he didn’t take it. The clock was running out and they hadn’t sold it yet.
“Henry,” she whispered between rounds. “Next time you’re on top of me, snap my bra strap. I’ll pretend to hate it. You’ll officially be off the bottom of the pecking order.”
His eyes went wide, but he nodded.
The whistle blew. Henry on top. Robin let him flatten her and went limp. He reached down and snapped the strap, tentative, barely a flick.
“Ow!”
He pulled it further the second time. The snap carried across the mats and a few heads turned.
“Ow! Quit it!” She squirmed under him, selling it, and Henry sat on her like he’d been doing this his whole life. A third snap, hard enough to sting for real.
“Coach! Henry is snapping my bra!” she yelled in her best whiny voice.
Coach blew his whistle. “That’s enough, Henry… I didn’t know you had that in you.” Two short blasts. “Hit the showers, ladies!”
Robin was the first person out of the gym, having decided that the panties were an acceptable loss if it meant getting out of the locker room unmolested. But Billy was quick too. Seeing him coming, she surreptitiously hid a pen in the back of her shorts.
He had two cronies with him. Nobody spoke; instead, one of them punched her in the stomach, knocking the wind out of her. She cried out, “Please somebody, help! Coach, help!” The reply she heard was the coach’s office door shutting. After that, the rest of the kids pretended not to hear or see. One covered her mouth. She kept trying to call out anyway, in the most pitiful voice she could manage, while they dragged her into the unused shower area. The corner they hauled her to could not be seen from the lockers at all.
The corner reduced their numerical advantage and they had chosen it themselves.
The acoustics were good, so while she was trying to decisively lose to Billy, she was also trying to create witnesses. When they pushed her to her knees and released her mouth she pleaded just loudly enough to be certain that she could be heard from the lockers, “Please, Billy, don’t hurt me.”
Billy pulled out a knife and his dick. “Okay, please don’t kill me, I’ll suck your dick,” she narrated.
And she did. Robin had learned the lesson well enough by now that this was an acceptable way to decisively lose. Let him win this and keep the witnesses for the future.
She’d been in showers like this before. This wasn’t as bad as with the older boys in Burke House and now she was a lot less scared of what buggering might be like. She had no difficulty breathing and staying calm.
Billy was getting pretty into it. “Guys, turn around, I can’t finish with you watching.” He started pulling Robin’s hair. Then he started talking. “I won’t kill you as long as you keep blowing me whenever I ask. Instead, I’m going to do you a favor and cut your cock and balls off so you can look more like a woman.” Robin looked in his face, then at the way he was holding the knife and recalculated. Too much was at stake.
She had already maneuvered one foot to be flat under her in case fleeing became an option. She reached back and gripped the pen, double-checked her calculations and then executed. At that moment, Billy’s eyes were closed, one hand held her hair and the other held a knife in front of her face, the easiest possible place for her to handle. Simultaneously she bit down hard, grabbed the wrist with the knife, drove herself up, and readied the pen to stab.
Of the four contingencies she planned for, she got the second best: He let go of her hair but tried to swing the knife. She kept a tight grip on his wrist but released her bite and in a smooth motion drove the pen about two centimeters into Billy’s eye. All this happened before the cronies could even turn around.
Billy tried to pull away but Robin kept her grip on his wrist. She kicked him in the ankle and lunged. It would have been a brutal takedown on a wrestling mat. When Billy landed, the tile reverberated with the sound of it, and when his head hit the floor, it vibrated.
Billy appeared to be unconscious and dropped the knife which was an even better outcome than the best one she had planned for. She picked up the knife while the two other boys looked on, frozen. Capitalizing on their shock, she yelled, “Go get help! You tell the coach to call an ambulance and you run to the nurse! Now!” The two of them ran out of the showers.
Robin sat huddled in the corner with her knees to her chest. “Please someone help!” she screamed as loud as she could. Then she tried forcing herself back into the tiny terrified body. When Douglas reached them, she hadn’t made much progress: there were no tears yet, but her whole body was shaking. Billy was already stirring, his groans getting louder.
“Billy, try to be still and keep your eyes closed,” Robin told him. “There’s a pen in your eye and you might make it worse if you move at all. Just try to keep calm.” At the same time she was still holding the knife out in his direction.
Billy’s hands went to his eye as his moan rose to a stream of swears. “Aah, Fuck! Shit Fuck!” He pulled out the pen and pressed both hands to his eye. “YOU’RE FUCKING DEAD, BITCH!”
The coach lifted the front of Billy’s shorts to cover his penis and then he came toward Robin saying, “Give me the knife.”
“Stay the fuck away from me!” screamed Robin. “HELP!”
Boys from the seventh period came in to gawk. Soon after, the nurse arrived breathing heavily to see Robin huddled in the corner holding a knife out toward the gym coach. She went immediately to Billy. “Get everyone back, I need to calm this down,” said the nurse to Douglas.
“This ain’t entertainment! Gym’s cancelled. Everyone report to the library for a study period,” boomed the coach.
As the nurse comforted and examined Billy, Robin slowly folded up the knife, took a deep breath, and spoke very fast. “Billy said he was going to use this knife on me and I believed him. In self-defense, I stuck him in the eye with a pen and disarmed him. I was waiting for more witnesses before surrendering Billy’s knife because I believe that Coach Douglas would have tried to cover up these facts, just like he covered up Billy’s penis.”
She took another breath, faster this time. “In addition to his eye and the back of his head, you should also examine the bite wound on his penis because he was forcing me to give him a blowjob at knifepoint when he made an additional threat that I believed to be more credible than his original ‘suck my dick or I’ll kill you.’ ” Then Robin slid the knife toward the nurse’s feet and went back to huddling.
Throughout that speech, Billy kept chiming in with, “Fuck that!” and “Bitch attacked me.”
Unable to help herself, Robin retorted, “How did I manage to attack you way over here in this private corner of the showers, Billy? I’m not the one with henchmen who can drag my enemies to someplace private. By all means, keep talking to the witnesses, but remember not to move or try looking around. Let the nurse help you.
“And Billy, I don’t intend to press charges as long as you and yours leave me alone from now on. I mean it. You lost, it’s time to let it go.”
“YOU’RE DEAD, BITCH!”
“Nurse, has anyone called my dad? Can you radio the office and have them send my big sister here? Athena Bertucci in the high school.”
Billy’s swears turned back into pained moans now with the sound of crying.
The nurse used her radio to make sure that Robin’s family was notified. She specifically asked for Athena to be sent there directly. “Coach Douglas, can you please make sure the exterior doors to the locker room and gym are unlocked? Thank you.” Douglas seemed hesitant but after a hard look from the nurse, he still did it.
“Thank you so much, ma’am.” And with that, Robin tucked her head and finally broke down the rest of the way.
By the time Athena arrived, Billy had calmed down and was back to only occasionally swearing about how much it hurt and what he was going to do to Robin. Athena brought Robin to a bench in the locker area to comfort her.
The paramedics arrived shortly after and the nurse spoke crisply and professionally to them. Robin felt a rush of relief when she heard, “Normal pupil, no blood, no fluid.”
A paramedic said, “It looks like you got really lucky, but we can’t be sure. We’re going to take you to the hospital to get checked out. We’re going lights and sirens even though it’s probably just a scratched cornea.” He said the last part cheerily, like it was supposed to be an adventure. “Those can still hurt like hell. We’ll get you something for the pain once we’re in the rig. It looks to me like all you’re in for is a week or two of discomfort and an eye patch.”
“I’m glad you’re going to be okay, Billy,” Robin said loudly, eliciting more curses from him. She turned to the nurse with a pleading look. “I choked up on the pen because I didn’t want to hurt him. I just needed to get the knife because he was trying to stab me after I bit him.” The nurse gave her a pained and sympathetic smile.
“Bit him? Where?” asked a paramedic.
“His penis. He was threatening me with the knife to make me suck it and I was Just Doing It,” she emphasized for Billy’s benefit. “But then he said he was going to cut me anyway. I believed him, so I had to act.”
The other paramedic peeked in his shorts and said, “Oh…” and exchanged a serious glance with his partner. “We’ll treat that on the way to the hospital.” They helped him onto their gurney and headed out.
The nurse was following them out when Athena called to her, “Hey, wait! My sister’s throat hurts, from… you know. Can you just check it out and make sure you write down what you see in whatever log book you have?”
The nurse hesitated but then found some courage and returned. She pulled out her trusty otoscope and a tongue depressor, asking Robin to say aaahh. Robin complied, and the nurse nodded gravely. “I’m sorry to ask this. Did he ejaculate?” Robin shook her head.
“I’ll make a note of the soft-palate irritation,” the nurse said, handing her a lollipop. “This is a prescription lollipop: specifically for soft-palate irritation.”
That made Robin smile. She thanked the nurse, then pulled her into a hug, whispering, “Please don’t leave. I’m scared of Coach Douglas.”
A shocked look crossed the nurse’s face, but she nodded. “I’ll stay until your father arrives.”
The nurse lingered near the lockers, her fingers working the stethoscope around her neck like a rosary. Athena’s arm tightened around Robin’s waist.
“Got everything?” Athena asked, low and steady.
Robin nodded, then froze. “My panties. Coach threw them in the trash in his office.”
The nurse’s eyes darted to the coach, then away. But Athena didn’t hesitate. “Stay here.”
“Don’t go in there!” Coach barked, but Athena was already moving, her boots heavy against the tile. The door swung open. She dug through the trash, retrieved the crumpled panties, and shoved them into Robin’s bag.
“Disgusting piece of shit,” Athena muttered under her breath. “We’re going to wait for our dad out front.” She helped Robin to her feet.
Coach stepped in front of the exit, arms crossed. “No, you’re not. Police are on their way.”
Athena didn’t slow. “She’s mine. And she’s done here.”
Robin clung to her, voice steady despite everything. “I already told the nurse everything. I’m not pressing charges.”
The coach’s fingers dug into Robin’s shoulder.
“Stop! You’re hurting me!” Robin’s voice cut through the room, sharp and clear. She looked at the nurse. Her pen was shaking. Robin watched her open her mouth, close it, and look at the floor.
Then the locker room door hit the wall with a bang and Dad was through it at a run, fists already up, shoulders tensed like a boxer’s. He pulled up short when he saw the coach, read the room in a second, relaxed his posture and unclenched his hands. But he didn’t drop them all the way.
“Let. Go.” He enunciated crisply.
The coach’s grip dropped. His face twisted, ugly and defiant. “Police are on their way. He’s not leaving.”
Dad didn’t raise his voice. “She is leaving. You have no right to detain her.”
The nurse stood perfectly still, clutching her clipboard with both hands.
“This is a crime scene—”
“Regardless of whether that is true,” Dad’s voice didn’t change, “I am entitled to take her home and you can’t stop me.”
The coach’s jaw worked. “You don’t know what happened.”
Dad’s chuckle was mirthless. “Oh, but I know more than enough about you and about my daughter.”
Athena shifted, “Dad, there’s another door. Follow me.”
Dad scooped Robin into his arms and followed Athena. The coach’s hand shot out, grabbing Dad’s arm.
“Last chance,” Dad said, quiet now. Dangerous. “Peons always need to be threatened before they listen. Fine. I’ll threaten.”
The coach’s Adam’s apple bobbed.
“Let me put this in terms you’ll understand. You’re not a player, Douglas,” Dad spat the name like it tasted foul. “You’re a spectator. And I was going to let you walk away from this. But I can just as easily remove you from the field.”
Dad leaned in. “If you don’t get out of my way, I will take you to the mat, and you will lose. No powerful friends. No second chances.”
The coach let go and took a small step back.
Athena held the door open, glaring, and Dad didn’t wait.
Over his shoulder, Robin caught one last glimpse of the nurse, still standing exactly where they’d left her, clipboard pressed to her chest, not moving, not speaking, not doing a damn thing.