Decisive Losses (part 3)
Content Warning: sexual assault, corporal punishment
The engine hummed, a low, steady vibration beneath Robin’s cheek as she lay across the bench seat, her breath shallow. The pants stuck to her skin, warm and damp with blood. Dad drove with one hand, the other resting on her shoulder, steady and still.
“You did good, my love,” he said, voice raw and soft, “real good.”
Robin didn’t respond; she pressed her forehead against the cool vinyl, eyes shut.
Dad exhaled, long and slow. “You’re allowed to be mad at me.”
The words didn’t compute.
“What happened back there?” His jaw worked. “It was fucked.” He shook his head. “Deeply, deeply unfair. And I made you do it…” The turn signal clicked, rhythmic. “So if you’re pissed, that’s fair. I’d be pissed too.”
Robin swallowed. Her voice came out a rasp. “I’m mad, just not at you.”
“Are you sure?”
She shook her head, just a little. “You didn’t have a choice.”
“Neither did you.” His voice cracked, just slightly. “That’s the whole damn point.”
Neither of them spoke. The headlights cut through the dark, illuminating the empty road in stark yellow slices.
“Billy’s dad,” Dad said finally, “he’s not a bad man. Just weak. And rich enough to never face consequences.” A bitter laugh. “Men like that? They raise monsters. Because why wouldn’t they? The world bends for them. Their kids grow up thinking rules don’t apply to them.” His fingers drummed against the seat. “But tonight? Tonight, Billy’s parents got a glimpse of what Billy could become while there’s still time to save him.”
Dad was talking more than he ever had before. “This isn’t important because we’re saving Billy, fuck him, we’re saving Billy’s future victims. We might have just saved the world from all of the damage one powerful monster can cause and that’s a lot.”
Dad’s mouth twisted. “I just had a great talk with his mom. His old man looked sick when he saw what Billy tried to do at the end. Things will change for Billy. We’ll see whether it changes him. It’s hard to imagine this not improving him at least a little.”
Robin’s eyes were still closed, her body curled in on itself against the seat. The pain pulsed with every breath, but she barely registered it; not when Dad’s words were still hanging in the air.
“What did Billy try to do at the end?”
Dad made a gasping sound that Robin couldn’t interpret. When he spoke, his voice was uncharacteristically hesitant. “I’m sure you could tell that he was getting frenzied. Could you hear his parents saying ‘enough’ but doing nothing to stop him?”
“Uh huh.”
“Well, it was obvious to me that he was getting sexual gratification and I could see he had an erection. So I whispered, ‘go ahead, fuck her.’ ” Robin gasped beside him. “But, Robin, I wasn’t going to let him, please understand that, I was right next to him. I wanted to make sure that his parents saw what I saw and they got their asses up off that fancy couch.”
Robin’s stomach lurched. And as she started to picture the scene: particularly the way Billy’s lips would’ve peeled back from his teeth, she became a spectator, not a participant. The disgust disappeared and the feeling of betrayal did with it.
“Smart… Lucky I didn’t hear though. Warn me next time.”
“It was a spur of the moment idea when I saw his erection and parents’ inaction. But that is fair criticism, I should have anticipated that possibility and discussed it with you just like I did with the scourge. I’ll do better next time.”
Next time. They were silent for a while until Robin quietly said, “He’ll be back.”
Dad didn’t answer right away. Then, softly: “Maybe not. One thing his mom asked about was military school. And if he does come back, he won’t be like before… Without the power of his dad, he’s just a boy. We’ll handle him.”
The truck slowed as they turned onto their street. The house loomed ahead, dark except for the porch light Athena must’ve left on.
Dad pulled into the driveway, killed the engine.
“Robin.” His voice was rough. “Look at m— no don’t, just listen. You did what you had to do,” he said. “And you did it well. At nearly every point. That’s all I can ask.” A beat. “I’m proud of you. And more than that,” he continued. “I respect your intellect. Swear to me that you won’t tell Athena what I’m about to tell you.”
Robin checked the oath against her intentions before saying, “I swear.”
“I think you’re more mature than her. From now on, I will treat you like the ‘young adult’ you are. I want you to think of me as a mentor, guide, and advisor first and ‘authority figure’ second. But I can’t extend the same to Athena, not quite yet. So it’s important that you don’t do anything to undermine my authority with her. She still needs another year or two of her dad telling her what to do in some ways that you might not. Do we have an understanding?”
Part of her noticed that Dad was still talking, still offering things unprompted, and that this was probably the best negotiating position she would ever have with him. She was too tired and too floaty to come up with something good.
Robin shifted on the bench seat, a low groan escaping as the movement pulled at every cut on her body. But she got her hand onto his where it rested on her shoulder, and squeezed. “We do.” She added the best ask she’d managed to think of, “Can I have my own key to the house?”
He smiled a tight smile that dimpled his chin, slid the key off the keyring and pressed it into her hand. Then he got out and opened the door for her and asked, “How do you want to do this?”
“Sack,” she said flatly. The movement sent fresh pain lancing through her, but she barely felt it.
She barely felt anything, least of all any emotions. She was still outside herself, still watching from above, and the girl draped over Dad’s shoulder was a distant thing made of meat. But Dad’s words had reached her somehow; not the feeling part, not the part that was supposed to hurt or be scared or cry. Something deeper. Something that looked at what they had done tonight and called it by its right name.
Heroic.
The word didn’t feel warm or even positive. It felt like a blade: cold, clean, and useful. She could picture a life spent standing opposite evil, even when it was terrifying, even when it cost her skin and blood and the ability to sit comfortably for a week. She had proven herself capable. That was not a feeling. It was a fact, logged and filed in the place where feelings couldn’t reach.
Billy was only her first monster. A baby monster. The warm-up. There would be more and that was fine. That’s how things were supposed to be.
The front door swung open before Dad even reached the porch. Athena stood framed in the doorway, her face pale under the harsh light. She took one look at the bundle over his shoulder and went white.
“Jesus Christ,” she whispered.
Dad adjusted his grip, the blanket shifting just enough to reveal Robin’s bloody pants. “She’s hurt. Nothing serious, but lots…” His voice was rough. “Take care of her like you said you would.”
Athena didn’t move, not at first. Her eyes flicked from Dad to the stiff way he held Robin, the way his knuckles were white around the fabric. Then she stepped aside, pressing herself against the doorframe to let him pass.
“You did this,” she said, flat.
Dad didn’t stop walking. “Yeah.”
“She’s twelve!”
“And she’s alive.” He didn’t look back. “Be mad at me later. Right now, she needs you.”
Athena’s throat worked. She reached out, fingers brushing the edge of the blanket as Dad carried Robin past her. The metallic smell of blood hit her as they passed. The knot in her stomach tried to escape her mouth.
The bathroom was ready. Athena had laid everything out while she waited: towels folded on the counter, washcloths stacked beside the tub, antibiotic ointment, gauze, medical tape, a bowl of warm water with a clean sponge. All of it was arranged with a precision that said she’d done it, undone it, and redone it at least twice.
“Draw her a bath,” Dad said. “Sit on the toilet seat.”
Athena twisted the faucet until steam curled into the air. Then she sat, hands clenched between her knees.
Dad set Robin on her feet, holding her with both hands while he scrutinized her face. After seeing what he was looking for, he loosened his grip and the blanket fell. He gently peeled the pants down while Robin winced.
Athena gasped audibly.
“I’m okay,” Robin mumbled. “Hugs, please?”
Athena jumped up to hug her and Dad watched the color drain from her face.
“No! Sit,” he commanded but it was too late. He let go of Robin and guided Athena back to the seat and from there down to the floor. “Put your feet up on the toilet, Athena. Robin, can I hug you?”
Robin was already kneeling at Athena’s side. “Yes, but…”
“You’ve never stood up too fast and almost fainted? She’ll be fine in under a minute.”
Robin nodded and wrapped her arms around him without taking her eyes off Athena. He reciprocated firmly.
“I’m fine now. Can I get up, Dad?” asked Athena.
“Slower this time, kiddo.”
When the tub was full and both kids’ faces had all the right colors, he turned to leave. “Do you want me to put your key someplace for you?”
Robin considered. “No thanks. I’ll hold it.”
“She’s all yours, Athena” he said. Then, at the door, “the stakes only get higher from here.”
He pulled the door shut behind him.
Athena’s hands shook. She wanted to scream at someone: Dad, MacDougal, Billy, Douglas, God, whoever was in charge of this. She wanted to wrap Robin in blankets and never let go. She wanted to kill something. Instead she had a naked, bleeding, twelve-year-old looking up at her like nothing was wrong.
“Let’s get you in the tub,” Athena managed.
Robin leaned on her as they crossed the two steps to the tub. She eased Robin down into the water. Robin hissed as the heat found the cuts. The red bloomed instantly, swirling in dark clouds.
“You know,” Robin rasped with a smile, “I’m feeling pretty sanguine about the whole thing.”
Athena blinked. “Well, I’m pissed.”
Robin opened her mouth to say more, then winced and touched her throat. She smiled instead, small, tired, private, and let it go.
Athena reached for the washcloth, dipped it under the water, and began to wipe, gentle, careful, her eyes burning.
Robin flinched.
“Sorry,” Athena whispered.
Robin shook her head, just slightly. “ ‘S okay.’’
It wasn’t. The water turned murky, the red deepening until it was the color of old rust. Athena’s hands didn’t stop moving. She gently, gently washed the blood off one part at a time. The washcloth came away pink, then red, then dark crimson.
Robin’s eyes stayed shut. “This is nice. I feel floaty. I’m just really sore, and tender.”
Athena’s throat burned. She drained the dark red tub, watched the water spiral away, the red thinning to nothing. Then she turned the faucet again, refilled it.
The second time, the water only got a little pink. While the tub was filling, she noticed Robin’s fist. “What’s in your hand?”
“Dad gave me his house key,” she said smiling broadly.
“And you brought it in the tub with you?”
“I’ve never had a key before. Will you help me not lose it?”
“Of course, little bird.” Athena felt bad for taking her key for granted and changed the subject. “Are you comfortable like that? That’s a good position for me to wash you in.”
Once every cut had been carefully washed, Athena gently patted her sister dry and walked with her to the bedroom. They stopped by the bookshelf and Robin put the key next to her garnet.
Athena laid her on the cot on her stomach and used most of a tube of antibiotic ointment on her. She then set to bandaging. But it was overwhelming so she called for Dad, “I don’t know how to bandage all this. She has cuts everywhere.”
Dad came back with a pair of adult incontinence briefs. Athena asked why he had them and he replied, “Don’t ask questions you don’t want to know the answers to.” Which made Robin giggle, which in turn finally unclenched the knot in Athena’s stomach a little bit. “I think you can let all the little scratches air out and this should protect her bum. But you’ll still need to tape some bandages at the bottom so it stays in place and covers all of them.”
Robin spoke again, “Me and dad were heroes just now, Athena. I’m proud of us. Dad, explain how there’s like a 30% chance that we just prevented, like, a hundred sexual assaults and other bad stuff. My throat is sore from… it’s been a very long day.”
Dad pulled up the desk chair, the legs scraping against the hardwood. He sat backward, arms folded over the top rail, his voice low but steady. “Billy MacDougal’s old man runs half the damn town. Cops, judges, the school board. Kid’s been untouchable since he was in diapers.”
Athena’s fingers stilled on the edge of the bandage tape. She didn’t look up, but Robin could see the way she went rigid, the way her hands went still.
Dad continued, “Billy’s not just some spoiled brat. He’s got a system. Starts small: pushing kids in the hall, stealing lunch money. Then it’s cornering girls and making them do things they don’t want to. Then it’s worse. And worse.” He leaned forward slightly, shadows cutting sharp lines across his face. “Kids like him? They don’t stop. They just get better at hiding it. And tonight, Robin exposed him to his parents.”
“We exposed him. Go ahead, fuck her was a brilliance.”
“The fuck?!” said Athena.
Dad hesitated before explaining, “Yeah, his chickenshit parents were wringing their hands while dear little Billy was making all of those little scratches. They needed a little push out the door. Which they got when Billy whipped out his Willy… at my whispered encouragement.”
“Get out of here you… you…” Athena raved, “let me comfort my too-damn-perfect sister who ought to hate your guts right now. And if she won’t, I’ll cover for it and hate you double.”
“The view must be nice from such a high moral highroad,” said Dad, smiling. “Goodnight, my darlings!”
“G’night,” said Robin.
“Eat shit!” said Athena.
Robin shifted against the pillows, her throat raw. “Water?”
Athena huffed, still vibrating with leftover anger, but she pushed off the bed and grabbed the half-empty bottle from the desk. The plastic crinkled as she unscrewed the cap. She stopped before handing it to her. “Hold on.” She dug through the drawer, fingers brushing past hair ties and loose change before closing around a bent straw.
“Here.” She held it out, the straw already angled toward Robin’s lips.
Robin took it and sipped. She drank with her eyes closed, the straw easier than tipping a bottle, and for a little while the only sound was her swallowing and the soft crinkle of the plastic.
She felt Athena go very still beside her.
“You’re staring, aren’t you.”
Athena’s voice was rough. “Yeah, well.” She cleared her throat. “Didn’t know seeing you like this would… Fuck with me so much.”
Robin didn’t understand, but she didn’t need to. “You could sing to me,” she murmured. “If you wanted.”
Athena blinked. “A lullaby?”
“Mhm.” Robin nestled deeper into the pillows. “Something soft.”
Athena didn’t move. Then she set the bottle on the desk and climbed into the bed. Her fingers found the edge of the blanket, tucking it snug around Robin’s shoulders. The warmth of her palm lingered against Robin’s back.
Then she started to hum.
Low, at first. Then words, quiet and unsteady.
“Rock-a-bye baby, in the treetop,
When the wind blows, the cradle will rock…
When the bough breaks, the cradle will fall,
And down will come Robin, cradle and all.”
Robin’s fingers curled into the sheets. Athena’s breath warmed the back of her neck, her lips brushing the shell of Robin’s ear on the last syllable. The mattress dipped as Athena leaned in closer, her hum turning into a whisper against Robin’s skin.
Her voice cracked on the last note. She cleared her throat, tried again from the beginning, softer this time. It wrapped around Robin like the blanket, like the dark, like the slow, sure press of Athena’s fingers carding through her hair.
Robin’s eyelids grew heavy. The pain was mostly just a memory and increasingly distant, muffled under the weight of Athena’s voice, the steady shush of her breathing.
“Sleep, little fury,” Athena whispered, her lips brushing Robin’s temple. “I’ve got you.”
The following week…
The junior high school boys’ bathroom smelled like industrial cleaner and piss. Athena waited in a stall, a small make-up mirror placed on the ground inconspicuously. The angle of the mirror was just right to see the door.
She’d been waiting twenty-three minutes.
Twice she’d almost left. The first time, a janitor came in and checked the soap dispensers and she’d frozen, heart slamming, the knife slick in her palm. The second time was worse: no external threat, just a voice in her head that sounded like Robin’s, quiet and precise: this is stupid, Athena. This is exactly the kind of thing Dad warned you about.
She’d pushed it down by remembering the color of the bathwater. The anger came back, hot and reliable.
Then he walked in.
Billy MacDougal, alone for once, his white sneakers squeaking on the tile. He unzipped with one hand, the other braced against the wall like he owned the place. Athena’s fingers opened the knife. They were shaking. She squeezed the handle until they stopped.
She gave him three seconds.
Then she stood.
The stall door creaked, but Billy kept to his business.
“Hey, Billy. Remember me?” She made sure he could feel the cold metal of the dull edge against his penis.
“Shut up and put your hands on your head.” Her voice came out steadier than she felt. “You and I are gonna have a little chat about Robin.”
“I… I didn’t do anything!”
The anger burned like white phosphorus behind her eyes, but she kept her voice level, like Dad would. “You raped her, Billy. And you beat her bloody.”
“No. My dad talked to yours, we got a deal—”
“Funny thing about that. I wasn’t part of that deal.” She dragged the knife downward, the dull side scraping. “See, I don’t give a shit what your dad says. Or mine. You touch her again? You look at her wrong? Or if you tell anyone about this? I’m gonna cut this little worm off and feed it to you.”
Billy’s breath came in short, panicked bursts. “I won’t! I swear—”
“Prove it. Hold out your dick so I can take a picture of her teeth marks.”
Billy whimpered and complied. Athena took the close-up of what were clearly a small person’s teeth marks. Evidence, she told herself. This is evidence.
“One more.” She grabbed his chin, forcing his face toward the mirror. His eyes were red-rimmed, his lower lip quivering. She took the shot, getting both the face and the penis.
“This is your one warning. Next time? No photos. Just surgery.”
Billy sagged against the wall, his slacks still undone, his face wet. Athena snapped the knife shut and shoved it in her pocket. Her hands were shaking again. She walked out without looking back.
Dad didn’t even look up from his coffee when Athena slid her phone across the kitchen table. The screen lit up his face: Billy’s dick, close-up, the teeth marks livid against his pale skin.
Athena set her jaw. “Evidence. Of what he did to Robin.”
Dad took a deep breath while he set his mug down. Slow. Deliberate. Then he stood.
Athena barely registered the movement when his hand shot out, gripping her wrist. The phone clattered to the floor as he dragged her toward the hallway, his steps heavy, unhurried. Like a man walking to a chore he’d done a hundred times before.
“Dad, come on—!”
The belt was already in his hand by the time they reached the living room. He doubled it over with a sharp crack against his own thigh, the sound making Athena’s stomach drop.
“You idiot,” he growled. “You think this is a game?”
“He deserves—!”
“Don’t care.” The first strike landed before she could brace, the leather biting across her jeans with a sound like a gunshot. Athena gasped, her fingers clawing at the arm of the couch. “You want to play enforcer? Fine. But you don’t undermine me. Not when I’ve got a truce hanging by a thread.” He punctuated his lecture with the belt.
“He’s scum—!”
Dad didn’t stop. “You want to protect her? Then you follow the rules. You don’t go rogue. You don’t make threats you can’t back up. You listen.” The belt kept cracking.
“And one more thing.” His voice went quiet, which was worse. “You held a knife to a boy’s dick and made him pose for pictures. You want to tell me how that’s different from what he did to her?”
Athena’s mouth opened. She could have answered, but she didn’t.
Instead, she unbuttoned and lowered her jeans before being asked to. Then she put her forehead back against the cushion.
The belt came down again and again. And she took the rest as bravely as she could.
Robin found her facedown on her bed, the waistband of her jeans peeled down, her skin striped with angry red welts.
Athena didn’t move as Robin sat beside her, fingers hovering over the worst of the marks. “He really got you good.”
Athena’s voice was muffled against the pillow. “Worth it.”
Robin uncapped the lotion. “You know it wasn’t.”
Athena nodded into the pillow. Then she turned her head just enough to watch as Robin squeezed a dollop onto her palm, rubbing her hands together to warm it. The first touch made her hiss, her back arching off the bed.
“Easy,” Robin murmured, her thumbs working slow circles over the hottest welts. “Just let me…”
Athena made a small sound. Her fingers curled into the sheets.
Robin’s touch was careful, methodical, her fingers tracing the lines of the belt like she was memorizing them. The lotion left a slick shine on Athena’s skin, the coolness seeping into the heat.
“Better?” Robin asked, her voice soft.
Athena swallowed. “Yeah.”
Robin’s hands didn’t stop.
After a while, Athena rolled over, her eyes dark.