Sister
Book 1: What is Best in Life?
Part 1: Sundress Weather
Sister
Sunday, September 23, 2012
Robin stared at the worn floorboards and decided they were a good amount of dirty. “Not much, but it’s ours,” Mark said, his tone warm but too big in the entry. “Meet Athena. She’ll be your sister.”
Athena stood a few feet away, her arms crossed over her chest, eyes locked on Robin. Her curiosity was showing through her aloof smirk. She was much taller than Robin, with short, dark hair, a safety pin in her eyebrow, and a fierce glint in her eyes. “Hi, Robin,” she said, her voice steady. “Nice to meet you.”
“Thank you for having me,” replied Robin. She could feel herself being sized up but there wasn’t much to size: four-foot nine, seventy-five pounds, and wiry, with dark brown eyes under a curtain of thick straight hair that had managed to avoid a barber for over a year. Her dark gray collared shirt and dark brown slacks, pleated a hundred wearings ago, would have been unremarkable in church, at school, or on a bus. Her once-white socks were clearly visible through holes in her gray sneakers.
Mark clapped a heavy hand on her shoulder; Robin tried to hide her flinch. “Athena, like we talked about, you two will share a room. They said you only had two outfits, is that right?”
“Yes, sir, but I have seven pairs of socks and underwear, sir.”
Mark nodded, pleased by the respect. “One sir will do; I don’t like sir-sandwiches.” His expression softened. “I’m also ‘Dad’ when you need me.”
“Yes, sir.”
“They were supposed to get you here earlier.” Mark rubbed his face. “We work with it. Athena, show your brother the washing machine and the box of your old clothes. Between those you should be able to make it through a week until we can buy you some new stuff. Athena has always been a bit of a tomboy.”
Robin didn’t cringe at brother, but did at tomboy. It was an awful word dressed up in cute clothes.
Robin could smell the damp entry mat as she stepped out of her sneakers and lined them up carefully by the door, even though she saw that Athena was wearing big black boots. “Thank you, sir,” she said, crisply.
On the way upstairs, Athena led a detour to the laundry. It was just a closet with a stacked washer-dryer inside. She said nothing, only gave it a loud kick. Robin followed her upstairs where she watched as her sister pulled a string that she herself would have needed a chair to reach. When Athena unfolded the steep attic stairs and climbed them, they creaked under her weight. Robin followed, her fingers brushing the faded wallpaper. The heat pressed down more with every step, close and heavy.
The attic opened up: slanted ceiling, exposed beams, the scent of dead bugs and mothballs. Late afternoon sunlight spilled in through the two grimy windows. Dust motes swirled in the light. “Here we go,” Athena said, stepping aside to let Robin pass.
The room was lined with boxes. Robin had trouble imagining how or why two people could have so many boxes.
Athena’s smirk deepened. She lifted a box from a stack and launched dust into the air when she dropped it on the floor. She crouched, rifling through it before pulling out a handful of shirts. “Here. Try these. They might not fit, but whatever.” She flipped over a drop-cloth to make a dust-free spot and started tossing clothes onto it.
Robin pawed through the offered clothes, first picking up a denim jacket that was probably okay. But as she lifted it, she saw that it had a bright pink lining that showed at the wrists and collar. She should have put it back down, but she didn’t.
Athena leaned against the stack of boxes, arms crossed again, but her stance was easier now. “You look happy.”
“I am happy.” She held the jacket against her chest and took a deep breath. “Athena?”
“Yeah?”
She swallowed. “I’m not a boy.”
Athena looked at Robin for a long moment, unmoving. “What do you mean?”
“I mean I’m a girl. I’ve always been a girl. There’s a word for it: transgender. It means I was born in the wrong body.” The explanation came out stiff, rehearsed, like she was reciting something she’d read online. Because she was. She’d found the word three months ago and read everything she could, terrified and relieved in equal measure that there was a name for it that wasn’t a slur.
Athena’s brow furrowed. She wasn’t disgusted, wasn’t angry; she was thinking. “So when Dad said ‘brother’…”
“I didn’t correct him.”
“Yeah, no kidding.” Athena looked at her, really looked, not at the clothes or the hair but at Robin’s face, and whatever she was seeing there. “So is that like… a cross-dressing thing?”
Robin flinched. “No. Cross-dressing is when you wear the clothes for fun. This is… I am a girl. All the time. Not just when I’m wearing a dress.”
“Okay.” Athena held up her hands. “Okay. Sorry. I don’t know the words for any of this.”
“Neither did I until three months ago,” Robin said quietly. “You’re the first person I’ve told.”
Athena’s fingers brushed the back of Robin’s wrist, just for a second. “I told Dad I was gay last year. He asked me if I was still doing my homework. You’ll be fine.” She grinned. “You ever had a sister before?”
Robin shook her head and didn’t mention the many, many “brothers” she had been counted among.
“Me neither.” She looked from Robin to the box. “Change of plans, let’s bring the whole box to my—I mean our room.”
The box thudded against Athena’s chest as Robin lowered it down the steep stairs. Athena caught it with ease, her biceps flexing under the weight. “Watch your feet,” she said, staying close. “Wouldn’t want you breaking your neck before you even see the room.”
Robin’s sock-clad toes curled against the warm wood, her balance steady despite the dizzying flutter in her stomach. She followed Athena down the hall, past a bathroom with a chipped sink, past a door slightly ajar, Dad’s room, probably. There wasn’t a single stray item on the floor, and she couldn’t remember seeing anything out of place downstairs either. Tidy enough to make her nervous.
Athena stopped and shoved open the last door on the left. “Ta-da.”
The room was cluttered and just large enough to feel big to a foster kid. A twin bed was shoved against the wall, its sheets rumpled and half-hanging off the mattress. Opposite the bed, a dusty cot sat slightly askew, a discarded shirt pinned under a leg. It blocked the bookshelf, and would have blocked the closet too, if it had a door.
Wedged between the bed and cot was a desk buried under books, a keyboard, a cathode ray tube monitor, and a lamp with a crooked shade. Behind the desk was the room’s window, the top part streaked nearly opaque. The floor was covered in a thin layer of discarded clothing, mostly black, but with flashes of bright color. A full-length mirror leaned against the wall in the corner like it had been fetched and then abandoned mid-use.
The walls were plastered with band posters—Paramore was the only one Robin recognized—and a collage of Polaroids and magazine cutouts: Athena mid-laugh, a cartoon toaster, Athena scowling, gigantic red lips turned vertical, Athena with her arm slung around some girl with short neon-pink hair.
Robin stood in the doorway and didn’t move. It was the perfect amount of messy.
Athena dropped the box onto the floor. “It’s a mess. Deal with it.”
Adults don’t inspect this room. “I love it,” Robin whispered.
Athena’s smirk softened as she watched Robin step inside and eye the mirror. She nudged the box gently toward it with her foot, her voice quieter now. “Yeah. Make it yours.”
Robin crossed the room to the mirror, her mirror now, her fingers brushing the edge. In it she saw a jaw that was still hers, and lips that were parted like she was about to say something clever.
Athena sat on the edge of the bed, slowly unlacing a boot while she watched. “Take your time,” she said, nodding toward the box. “Try whatever you want.”
Robin’s cheeks burned. “Can I… can we?”
Athena affected uninterest. “Of course. It’s yours now. I’ve outgrown it all either in size or in style.” She kept her posture relaxed, but her eyes never left Robin.
Robin went through the fabrics slowly, skimming past lace and denim and cotton until her hands stopped on something soft. A simple sundress, faded to the pale blue of a sky cooling toward evening. She lifted it out and held it against herself. The hem brushed her knees. She made a sound she didn’t recognize, half-laugh, half-sob, and pressed the fabric flat against her stomach with both palms. The dress wasn’t fancy. It wasn’t new. But it was hers.
The gray shirt and brown slacks landed in the corner of the room and then the dress slipped over Robin’s head, and for the rest of her life the smell of mothballs would be a pleasant one. The straps were thin enough to feel like nothing at all. The fabric settled against her skin. The air moved against her legs.
The girl in the mirror went still. Not a stranger this time. Not a boy in a costume. It was her.
Everything she owned was brown or gray. In blue she looked warm. Her shoulders were narrower than she’d thought. And her collarbones, which had only ever been proof that nobody was feeding her, caught the light and looked like they belonged to a girl.
Athena didn’t move from the bed, one boot half-off, the other still laced.
“Fits okay?” Athena’s voice had gone quiet.
Robin nodded, not trusting her voice. She lifted her hands, turning them palm-up as if checking for cracks, half-expecting the illusion to shatter.
After a few more loose dresses, Athena eyed Robin’s underpants and wrinkled her nose. “You can’t try on anything form-fitting until we get you out of those. There should be some of my old panties in there too.”
Robin’s fingers flew to the waistband of her briefs, nails digging into the frayed elastic. The room tilted. And then she dissociated. It had happened before, in other rooms, with other people. Part of her went cold and clear and separate while the rest of her hid under a bed.
Athena’s giggle died in her throat. Her hand stilled in the box. “Relax. It’s just underwear.”
Just underwear. Like it was nothing. Like it wasn’t the first time someone had seen her, not the boy they’d tried to carve her into, but the girl she’d buried under years of denial and shame.
The cold part of her mind said: She’s safe. Do it. The rest of her couldn’t breathe.
Athena stood, slowly, in one boot, like Robin was a skittish animal. “Hey.” A single step closer. “You want help?”
Robin shook her head, then nodded, then…
Athena’s hands were warm when they closed over Robin’s wrists. Not pulling, not pushing, just there. The cold clarity dissolved. She was one person again, and Athena’s thumbs were pressing against her pulse, and her breathing was slowing to match.
Athena’s thumbs brushed the backs of Robin’s hands before letting go. “Better?”
Robin’s laugh was shaky, disbelieving. “Yeah.”
“Good.” Athena grinned. “We’re almost to the fun part.” She turned, rummaging in the box before pulling out a fistful of panties and a little black dress. “Everybody looks sexy in a little black dress.”
Robin picked plain cotton panties with cartoon characters and changed facing the corner. She tried her best to smooth the front but it wasn’t working very well. Eventually, she took a deep breath and turned around. “I’m not sure I can wear a tight dress looking like this.”
Athena didn’t flinch. She just crossed her arms, head tilting like she was sizing up a puzzle. “You’re not looking like anything. You’re just you.”
“But—”
“Sit.” Athena removed a dog-eared copy of The Bell Jar from the desk chair and Robin replaced it. Athena pushed a button and the screen flickered to life with a whine, casting blue light over her sharp features. “We’ll fix it.”
Robin perched on the edge of the chair, knees pressed together, while Athena typed and clicked.
“Okay,” Athena muttered, squinting at the screen. “Yeah. Here.” She turned the monitor slightly, nudging Robin’s shoulder. “Read.”
Robin leaned in. The website was plain: no frills, just text and diagrams. “Tucking 101: A Beginner’s Guide.” She read it twice, then a third time, her lips moving.
She was on her feet before she realized it. “I want to try.”
Athena smirked. “Damn right you can. B.R.B…” She disappeared into the hall and soon returned with a roll of medical tape. “Jackpot.”
Robin’s bashfulness was gone. She pulled down the cartoon panties and then carefully taped herself according to the instructions.
Athena watched, arms crossed, her expression soft. “How’s it feel?”
It ached. Her ovaries were up inside where they belonged but it was tight.
Robin pulled the panties back up and exhaled, her hands pressing against her stomach. Flat. Smooth. She turned to the mirror, her reflection stranger and more hers than ever. Then she noticed the two new bulges an inch or two above where she had been looking. She decided that she wasn’t going to care about that today. “It works,” she said.
Athena’s eyes gleamed. “Told you.” She handed over the black dress. “Now. Let’s see what you’ve got.”
Robin turned in the mirror, and the girl looking back was someone unafraid, someone ready to be seen. Her hips were straight and narrow, but Athena had been right, she looked good in the dress.
“Try this!” said Athena, handing her a padded training bra. “See how you’ll look with tits!”
Robin’s cheeks burned, but she didn’t argue. She peeled off the dress, donned the bra, and put it back on again.
“Damn, Robin, you’re sexy. That’s almost too good.” She explained with a chuckle. “Jailbait. You cannot wear that to school.”
Robin didn’t cringe at the word; she liked it.
Robin tried on everything in the box and a fair amount of Athena’s current wardrobe. An hour vanished, then another.
The doorknob rattled before it turned. Robin froze mid-spin, the training bra clinging to her ribs, her legs tangled in a pair of ripped fishnets that she was trying to pull up under a pleather miniskirt. The door swung open, and Dad’s broad shoulders filled the frame. He wore a full beard with hard lines shaved along the throat and cheeks. His clothes were boring.
His gaze flicked over them—Robin half-dressed, Athena sprawled in a pile of clothes like a queen holding court—and his brow furrowed.
“Christ,” he muttered. “You two been up here how long?”
Athena didn’t flinch. “Fashion emergency. You know how it is.”
Dad’s jaw tightened. His eyes landed on Robin, lingering on the bra, the fishnets. He rubbed his face like his head hurt. “So you’re gay too?”
They both answered at the same time.
“No,” said Athena.
“I like girls… mostly… I think,” said Robin, her voice shrinking.
Her hands went to the button of the skirt. Athena’s hand shot out, gripping her wrist. “She’s not changing back.”
“I didn’t ask him to.”
Athena stood and planted herself between them. “Didn’t ask her to,” she corrected. “Robin is transgender, Dad. It means she was born in the wrong body. She’s a girl. She’s always been one.”
Dad’s eyes studied Robin’s face. Her fishnet-clad toes curled against the floorboards while she forced herself to hold his gaze.
He was quiet for a few seconds. Then he said, “Is this going to be a problem at school?”
It was such a dad thing to say that Athena almost laughed. “Probably.”
“Right.” He rubbed his temples. “We’ll deal with it.” He looked at Robin again, and his voice got quieter. “This is how it is?”
“It is… Dad.” Robin said.
He nodded once, the way he’d nod at a mechanic telling him the transmission was shot: not happy about it, but already past the part where not liking it mattered. “Okay. Put on a shirt and then it’s chores and dinner.”
“Yes, sir,” said Robin.
Athena’s grip on Robin’s wrist loosened, her thumb brushing the inside in a quick stroke. “Told you,” she murmured, just for Robin. Then she turned, snatching a discarded pastel t-shirt from the floor and tossing it at Robin. “Put that on over that chest of yours.”
Robin caught it and pulled it on. The cotton was thin enough that the red bra showed through.
Athena grabbed her hand, fingers threading together. “Come on, sister.” She tugged Robin toward the door, past Dad, who stepped aside with an approving grunt. On the way past, Robin noticed that he smelled like coffee.
The cot’s metal frame screeched as Athena dragged it across the floor, the legs catching on the uneven boards, muscles flexing under her tank top as she shoved it flush against the side of her bed.
The two of them took a trip to the garage and each came back with an armload of bricks. Robin carried the same number as Athena and tried to hide how difficult it was. Athena lifted the cot while Robin crawled underneath and wedged them under the cot’s legs one by one.
“Perfect,” Athena muttered, stepping back. The two sleeping surfaces were level and the mattresses were pressed together. She turned to Robin, hands on her hips. “No rolling into the abyss tonight.”
“I don’t—” Robin’s words tangled. She forced them out. “School. As a girl. What if—”
Athena sat up, swift and sharp. “What if what?” She interrupted. “Someone’s an asshole? Someone notices?” She sat heavily on the cot and pulled Robin down next to her. “Robin, listen to me.” She waited until Robin’s gaze flickered up, hesitant. “You think it’s easier to start out pretending to be something you’re not, just to switch later? To let them get used to a fake and then drop you on them like a bomb?” She shook her head. “No. You go in as you. You own it. And if anyone’s got a problem with it, they answer to me.”
The certainty in Athena’s voice was a physical thing. Robin nodded once, sharp. Then Athena’s expression softened. “Good.” She stood. “Now…clothes for tomorrow. Smart clothes. First impressions and all that bullshit.”
Robin perched on the mattress, her legs pulled tight against her chest. The dress from earlier was a splash of blue draped over the desk chair. She should’ve felt exhausted. She was exhausted. But her mind raced, thoughts skittering like mice in the walls.
Athena nudged her knee. “Hey. You’re doing that thing again.”
Robin blinked. “What thing?”
“That staring at nothing thing.” Athena leaned forward, elbows on her knees. “You’re not just nervous about school. What’s up?”
The words came out before she could stop them. “I’m… not like you. My brain… it doesn’t work right.”
Athena didn’t flinch. She just waited.
Robin swallowed. “I can’t… focus. Not on what I need to. And sounds, they get too loud, or too much, and I—” She pressed her palms against her temples. “I just… check out. And sometimes I don’t come back for a while.” Her voice dropped. “I’m bad at life. I forget things. Important things. I lose stuff. I ruin things. All the time.”
The bed creaked as Athena shifted closer, her shoulder brushing Robin’s. “You’re not bad at life.”
Robin’s laugh was bitter. “I’m difficult. Why do you think no one else would keep me?”
Athena reached for Robin’s wrist and held it. “You think I don’t know what it’s like to be the kid no one wanted?”
Robin said nothing; she didn’t want to lie.
Athena’s voice went quiet. “My mom split when I was six.”
“Mine too,” blurted Robin.
“She left me with him.” A jerk of her chin toward the hallway, where Dad’s shadow had passed minutes ago. “You think the mob’s full of warm, fuzzy dad types? He took me because he had to. Not because he wanted to.” Her grip tightened, just enough to feel. “But here’s the thing, Robin. He kept me. And now? He’s keeping you.”
“That’s not—”
“Not the same?” Athena’s laugh was bitter. “No. It’s not. Yeah, your brain works different. So what? Mine’s got a hair trigger and a mean streak. Mark’s got a God complex and a belt collection.” She leaned in, close enough that Robin could see the flecks of gold in her dark irises. “We’re all broken. But we’re here together.”
“I… I’m sorry. I’m scared about tomorrow. I have no right feeling sorry for myself in this place,” Robin said with a glance around their room: the bed, the clothes, and the sister. “I think we both could use a hug right now.”
“Ya think?” replied Athena, who wrapped her in a tight hug.
“I know you’re sitting here worrying about school when you just came out and tried on your first real dress.” Her hand found Robin’s, fingers threading together. “That’s not stupid. And it’s not being bad at life.”
Robin’s eyes burned. “It’s not stupidity, it’s being bad at everything people say is easy. Tests say I’m a genius, but if something is boring, I can’t make myself do it. Everyone calls me lazy all the time. They yell at me like, ‘If you can do A then clearly you’re capable of B!’ and I must be lazy, or weak-willed or something.”
Athena squeezed her hand. “So I’ll help.”
Robin shook her head. “You can’t just—”
“I can.” Athena’s voice was firm. “I’ll be your shadow. I’ll take notes for you. I’ll remind you of shit. And if you check out, I’ll bring you back.” She grinned, sharp. “I’m good at getting attention. Especially the bad kind.”
Robin’s breath trembled. “But… Why?”
Athena’s smirk faded, but only briefly. “Because you’re mine now.” She said it like it was obvious.
Robin’s chest ached. She nodded, her fingers clinging to Athena’s.
Athena tugged Robin up from the cot. “Alright. Operation First Day starts now.” She spun Robin toward the closet, giving her a gentle shove. “Pick an outfit. Something that says ‘fuck with me and die.’”
Robin laughed shakily, turned and then hesitated. “Athena?”
“Yeah?”
“Little decisions like which clothes to wear count as easy things I’m bad at. I can do it now because this is new and scary and exciting,” she picked up the blue dress that had spoken to her earlier. “But, I’ve always worn the same thing every day to make things easier. That was also because I was hiding myself. Will you please pick my clothes for me? Help me be the pretty girl I want to be without it becoming something I’m anxious about messing up?”
“I’d love to, little bird,” Athena replied, taking the dress. “This is perfect. Cute and plain.” She picked socks and panties and suddenly her clothes for the next day were all laid out.
She folded the little black dress and put it on a high shelf. “Not to school.”
“No?”
Athena almost made a joke before realizing that her new sister had absolutely no idea. “It’s not just the creeps, there are teachers who’ll never forgive you for giving them a hard-on. Not to mention the ones who’ll hate you for being younger and prettier than they are.”
Robin stared at her wide eyed.
“Now we pack. Bookbag first.”
They worked in silence, Athena’s movements sure and efficient as she guided Robin through the motions. Athena dumped the contents onto the bed: a second outfit, gray and brown and wrinkled, some more socks and briefs, a toothbrush, a sharpie on a necklace of string held by layers of fraying duct-tape, a few coins, a small purple stone, and a book. Athena almost threw the boys’ clothes away before she realized that Robin had arrived with only this bag and the clothes on her body. So instead she put them into the box with the dregs of her own clothes. She then handed Robin the book, a hardcover copy of Thinking, Fast and Slow with a Mylar cover and a barcode that said, “Dayton Public Library.”
Robin took her stolen book, blushing, and placed it in a gap in Athena’s bookshelf, making it their bookshelf.
Athena ripped the used pages from some of her own notebooks, and then handed them to Robin.
“Label these,” she ordered, grabbing Robin’s Sharpie and uncapping it with her teeth. “Name, class, my phone number.” She scribbled the digits onto the inside of the cover of the first notebook.
Robin was relieved to have her marker back. Her handwriting was messy, her letters slanting wildly.
When Robin’s bag was packed, Athena handed her one of her own T-shirts: over-sized, soft, smelling like her. “Nightshirt,” she said. “Wear it.”
Robin took off her shirt and the skirt and then fumbled with the bra. Athena helped without being asked. Then she let Athena pull the nightshirt over her head. It hung to her thighs. She brought the collar up to her nose and breathed in and her eyes closed.
The two of them brushed their teeth together. Athena sat to pee without warning or comment and her lack of self-consciousness was contagious. Robin winced as she slowly removed the tape. She realized too late that she should have tried to go pee first; the 101 website had given pointers on that particular complexity and she could have used the practice before school.
Back in the room, Athena stripped down and Robin tried not to stare at her big sister’s perfect body. Athena put on satin boxer shorts and they climbed into their beds.
“Goodnight, little bird.” Athena kissed the top of her head, then her forehead, then, hesitating just long enough for Robin to feel the question, the corner of her mouth.
“Goodnight, sister.”
Athena turned off the lamp and the room went dark except for a strip of moonlight through the blinds. Robin lay on her side, the shirt bunched under her chin, listening to Athena’s breathing two feet away and knowing she wasn’t asleep either.